A
new clinical trial looks at how psilocybin compares to a commonly prescribed
antidepressant.
- About
5% of adults worldwide live with depression.
- One
commonly prescribed medication for treating depression is selective
serotonin reuptake inhibitors (SSRIs), which have quite a few potential
side effects.
- Researchers
from Imperial College London in the United Kingdom say that psilocybin
provides similar improvement of depression symptoms as an SSRI.
- They
found that participants also reported greater improvements in social
functioning and psychological connectedness after 6 months.
Researchers estimate that 5% of adultsTrusted Source around
the world live with depression —
a mental health condition that causes a person to feel sad, hopeless, and/or
unable to experience joy.
In addition to psychological counseling, there are
several types of antidepressant medications available to
treat depression. One of the most commonly prescribed are selective
serotonin reuptake inhibitors (SSRIs)Trusted Source.
As with
all medications, SSRIs have
side effects that can include nervousness or anxiety, headache, nausea, dry
mouth, sleeping issues, and loss of libido. Additionally, past studies show
that SSRIs do not work for about 30% of
people with depression.
Now, researchers from Imperial College London in the
United Kingdom say that psilocybin —
a psychedelic compound found in certain types of mushrooms — provides similar
improvement of depression symptoms as an SSRI, as well as better psychosocial
functioning and other long-term benefits.
The study was recently published in the journal Lancet
eClinical MedicineTrusted Source and
presented at the 37th European College of
Neuropsychopharmacology (ECNP) Congress.
Psilocybin
offers same depression symptom improvement as SSRIs
For this study,
researchers recruited 59 adults with a diagnosis of moderate-to-severe
depression. Thirty participants received two 25-milligram doses of psilocybin,
while the remaining 29 followed a 6-week course of an SSRI called escitalopram.
Participants also received about 20 hours of
psychological support.
At the study’s conclusion, researchers found that both
groups showed notable improvement in their depression symptoms, even up to the
6-month follow-up.
“[Psilocybin]
disrupts the persistent ruminative loops of negative thinking that underpins
depression,” David Nutt, DM, FRCP, FRCPsych,
FMedSci, DLaws, the Edmond J. Safra Professor of
Neuropsychopharmacology and director of the Neuropsychopharmacology Unit in the
Division of Brain Sciences at Imperial College London and one of the authors of
this study, told Medical News Today.
“We did show that remission rates were much higher for
psilocybin than for escitalopram even though the mean scores for depression
reductions were not different,” he added.
“The reasons for this are complex and likely due to
high variability of some scores and the fact that after the two month treatment
trial, we did not control what the patients took in terms of medicines, i.e.
they could seek out other treatments,” Nutt explained.
Psilocybin
improves social functioning after 6 months
Additionally, in the
psilocybin group, participants also reported significant advancement in social
functioning and psychological connectedness during the 6-month follow-up.
“This is important because improving connectedness and
having greater meaning in life can significantly enhance a person’s quality of
life and long-term mental health,” David Erritzoe, MD, PhD, MRCPsych, clinical
director and deputy head of the Centre for Psychedelic Research at Imperial
College London and co-first author of the study stated in a press release.
“The study suggests that psilocybin therapy might be a
more holistic treatment option for depression, addressing both the symptoms of
depression and overall well-being. This could make a substantial difference in
the overall happiness and daily activities of those suffering from depression,
providing a more joined-up approach to mental health treatment,” Erritzoe
advised.
As to Nutt, he also pointed out that:
“This further supports the
view that psilocybin works quite differently to escitalopram, especially that
it doesn’t suppress emotions like escitalopram does. Just 2 psilocybin doses
are at least as effective at treating depression as 6 weeks treatment with
escitalopram with better remission rates and improved well-being outcomes up to
6 months.”
“We will be reporting outcomes of psilocybin treatment
in anorexia, OCD [obsessive-compulsive
disorder], and fibromyalgia next year,” he told us. “Our
current research is exploring if just a single dose of psilocybin can help
treat addictions to heroin and gambling.”
Promising
results for possible antidepressant alternative
After reviewing this
study, Simon B. Goldberg, PhD,
Kellner Family Distinguished Chair in Education and Well-Being and associate
professor in the Department of Counseling Psychology and Core Faculty at the
Center for Healthy Minds at the University of Wisconsin – Madison, who was not
involved in the research, told MNT that he thought it was very exciting that
work investigating alternatives to antidepressants is showing these kinds of
promising results.
“Depression is extremely common and burdensome, so
there is a huge public health need for effective treatments,” Goldberg
explained. “It was quite intriguing that the psychedelic condition was showing
benefits above and beyond escitalopram on some measures of well-being.”
“Although
antidepressants are helpful for many people, they have some important
limitations,” he continued. “Many patients do not respond to them, they can
have substantial side effects, and benefits may not persist when someone stops
taking the antidepressant. There is some evidence that there also may be
withdrawal symptoms associated with discontinuing antidepressants.”
MNT also
spoke with David Merrill, MD, PhD, a
board-certified geriatric psychiatrist at Providence Saint John’s Health Center
in Santa Monica, CA, and Singleton Endowed Chair in Integrative Brain Health,
about this study.
“The mind-altering and intensive nature of
psychedelics makes it such that comparing the two is nice in theory but the
access barriers for one treatment versus the other remain significant,”
Merrill, who was also not involved in the research, pointed out.
“It will take some doing before the comparable
effectiveness matches the realistic opportunity for patients to access the two
treatments equally,” he added.
Merrill said it is important for researchers to
continue to look for alternatives to standard SSRIs as it helps us understand
mechanisms of depression.
“There
may be ways to achieve the benefits of psychedelics without the drugs,” he
noted. “For example, through holotropic
breathingTrusted Source.
But even that can be of an intensity such that it’s recommended to be tried
only under direct supervision of an experienced practitioner.”
More studies
needed before psilocybin can be approved for depression treatment
Matthew W. Johnson, PhD, senior investigator at the Sheppard
Pratt Center of Excellence for Psilocybin Research and Treatment in Baltimore,
MD — who reviewed this study for MNT — pointed out that psilocybin has not been
approved for depression by the Food and Drug Administration (FDA), the European
Medicines Agency (EMA), or similar regulatory bodies.
“Therefore
it is important to move toward and complete phase 3 trials to potentially
garner that approval,” Johnson continued. “Such larger studies are also better
able to study the risks of psilocybin, which is something I have researched
over the years.“
“Larger studies are better equipped to identify
relatively uncommon adverse effects. We need to know how prevalent such effects
are under clinical conditions and optimize screening and treatment methods to
minimize harm,” Johnson explained.
Finally, MNT also spoke with Rachel Yehuda, PhD,
Endowed Professor of Psychiatry at the Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai
and director of The Parsons Research Center for Psychedelic Healing at Mount
Sinai, who commented this is an important study showing that the long term
effects of both psilocybin and escitalopram are durable six months after
treatment.
“This is the kind of information that the field needs
in order to understand long-term impacts of psychedelic therapies,” Yehuda, who
was not involved in this research, explained.
“What I really liked about this study is that we are
finally starting to talk about outcome measures beyond symptom severity, which
in mental health, can be extremely informative. Many people with symptoms can tolerate
them better if they can live lives full of meaning, connectedness, and social
functioning. Simply measuring severity of depression or other mental health
conditions often does [not] give the full picture of well-being,” she told us.
“That said, the study also calls for more long-term
follow up of psychedelic therapies as there is a suggestion in the data,
particularly in the supplementary tables, that the magnitude of the symptom
severity differences are reduced over time in the psilocybin group compared to
the escitalopram group. Again, if overall people feel like their lives have
improved, this argues for a more diverse set of primary outcomes in evaluating
the efficacy and long-term benefits of any mental health treatment.”– Rachel
Yehuda, PhD.