Ban on public events can bring down COVID-19 transmission rate by 24 per cent: Lancet study

Pupils at Martin-Buber-Oberschule secondary school wear protective masks against the spread

of the coronavirus disease as school resumes following the autumn holidays in Berlin on

October 26, 2020. 

Ban on public events can bring down the COVID-19 reproduction number ‘R’ number—a key

measure of virus transmission—by 24 per cent in less than a month, according to a modelling

study published in The Lancet journal.

An R value above 1 indicates a growing outbreak, whereas an R value below 1 indicates a

shrinking outbreak.

The research using data from 131 countries suggests that individual measures, including

closure of schools and workplaces, ban on public events and gatherings of more than 10 people,

requirements to stay at home, and internal movement limits, are associated with a reduction in

transmission of SARS-CoV-2.

However, combined measures are more effective at reducing transmission, the researchers said.

“We found that combining different measures showed the greatest effect on reducing the

transmission of COVID-19. As we experience a resurgence of the virus, policymakers will

need to consider combinations of measures to reduce the R number,” said Professor Harish

Nair from the University of Edinburgh, UK.

“Our study can inform decisions on which measures to introduce or lift, and when to expect to

see their effects, but this will also depend on the local context—the R number at any given

time, the local healthcare capacity, and the social and economic impact of measures,” Nair said.

When looking at the measures individually, a ban on public events was associated with the

greatest reduction in R -- 24 per cent reduction after 28 days—which the researchers suggest

may be because they are likely to prevent super spreader events and it was often the first

measure to be introduced in countries.

The measures most strongly associated with an increase in R were lifting bans on gatherings

of more than ten people and re-opening of schools, according to the researchers.

Although reopening schools was associated with a 24 per cent increase in the R by day 28, the

researchers caution that they were unable to account for different precautions some countries

implemented for reopening schools, for example limiting class sizes, distancing measure,

routine deep cleaning, personal handwashing, face masks, and thermal temperature checks on

arrival.

They said these are essential for safer school reopening and should be taken into account when

interpreting this finding.

“We found an increase in R after reopening schools but is not clear whether the increase is

attributable to specific age groups, where there may be substantial differences in adherence to

social distancing measures within and outside classrooms,” Nair added.

“Furthermore, more data are needed to understand the specific role of schools in increased

SARS-CoV-2 transmission through robust contact tracing,” he said.

The study, however, does not account for other potentially influential factors that have an

impact on R—including, among other things, compliance with the interventions, changes in

population behaviour, sub-national differences in R, or the effects of contact tracing and

isolation – all of which vary by context.

Using the R number as a proxy for transmission also has limitations, as it is difficult to estimate

accurately, particularly when prevalence is low, the researchers said.

In this modelling study, data on daily country-level estimates of R were linked with data on

what measures those countries had in place from January 1, 2020 to July 20, 2020.

The timeline of each country was divided into individual phases when all measures remained

the same in that country.

The analysis included 790 phases from 131 countries and the authors used a model to measure

the association between which measures were in place and changes in the R.

Source: https://www.tribuneindia.com/news/health/ban-on-public-events-can-bring-down-covid-19-

transmission-rate-by-24-per-cent-lancet-study-161419